top of page
Search

Are Financial Advisors Worth It? What Good Advice Can Do

Writer: Jeff Albaneze
Jeff Albaneze
Oct 27
9 min read
Financial Advisors

Are financial advisors worth it? It’s a fair question, and most of the industry answers it the wrong way. The pitch is usually some version of “we’ll beat the market.” The evidence says be skeptical of anyone who promises that.


A good advisor earns the fee somewhere else: in how you save, how you draw down your accounts in retirement, what you pay in taxes and how your assets pass to your family. Those decisions are concrete, and they can be worth far more than the fee. Here’s the honest case, followed by five strategies I use with clients that show what real value looks like.


Don’t hire an advisor to beat the market


The record for professional stock picking is hard to defend, and it has been for decades.

  • Most professionals lose to the index. In 2025, 79% of active large-cap U.S. stock funds trailed the S&P 500. Over five years, the underperformance rate was about 89% (S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA U.S. Year-End 2025; SPIVA By the Numbers).

  • Winners don’t stay winners. Outside small caps, none of the top-quartile domestic stock funds from 2021 were still in the top quartile by the end of 2025 (SPIVA Persistence Scorecard Year-End 2025). Last year’s star manager tells you little about next year.

  • Taxes widen the gap. In S&P’s 2024 after-tax scorecard, the median active large-cap core fund trailed the S&P 500 after taxes over every period measured, by as much as 4.4 percentage points a year (S&P Dow Jones Indices).

  • Hedge funds didn’t fix it. In Warren Buffett’s famous 10-year bet (2008–2017), a plain S&P 500 index fund compounded at 7.1% a year. A basket of hedge funds chosen by a professional fund-of-funds manager averaged 2.2% (CNBC).


These studies measure funds, not financial advice. But they show why outperformance is a weak promise to build a relationship on. A sound portfolio starts with diversification, low cost and a level of risk that fits your goals. Then the real work begins.


Where financial advice actually adds value


Useful advice shows up in decisions you control: which accounts to fund, how to manage taxes, when to draw from each account and how your investments fit your estate plan. Those decisions affect your wealth no matter what the market does.


Vanguard’s Advisor’s Alpha research estimates that disciplined advice can add about 3% a year in net returns. Vanguard is clear that this isn’t a guaranteed annual gain. The value varies by client and arrives unevenly: close to zero in a calm year, worth far more in a market panic or a retirement transition.


One of the biggest pieces of that estimate has nothing to do with taxes: behavior. In early April 2025, U.S. stocks came close to bear-market territory before recovering to finish the year up 18% (S&P Dow Jones Indices). An investor who sold in the panic locked in the loss and missed the rebound. Talking a client out of that one decision can be worth more than every strategy below combined.


So the better question isn’t “Did you beat the S&P 500?” It’s “What did you do that I wouldn’t have done on my own, and what was it worth?” Here are five strategies that answer it.


1. Backdoor Roth IRA contributions, for you and your spouse


If your income is above the limit for direct Roth IRA contributions, the backdoor Roth gets you there legally. You make a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA, then convert it to a Roth.


For 2026, the Roth IRA phaseout for married couples filing jointly runs from $242,000 to $252,000 of modified adjusted gross income. The IRA limit is $7,500 per person, so a couple under 50 can move $15,000 a year into Roth accounts this way (IRS).


Done every year, that adds up. At a hypothetical 7% annual return, $15,000 a year for 20 years grows to about $615,000, assuming end-of-year contributions and no fees. Qualified Roth withdrawals are tax-free, and Roth IRAs carry no required minimum distributions for the original owner.


Where it goes wrong: the pro-rata rule. When calculating the tax on a conversion, the IRS looks at your traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA balances together, as of year-end. Each spouse is tested separately, so one may qualify cleanly while the other needs cleanup. If your employer plan accepts incoming IRA rollovers, moving pretax IRA money into it first often solves the problem.


2. The mega-backdoor Roth


Most people think their 401(k) tops out at the employee deferral limit, $24,500 for 2026. It doesn’t have to. The total that can go into a 401(k) from all sources is $72,000 for 2026, subject to your compensation and plan rules (IRS). Some plans let you fill that gap with after-tax contributions, then convert them to Roth.


For example, an employee under 50 who defers $24,500 and receives $10,000 in employer contributions could have up to $37,500 of additional room. Converted promptly, that money grows tax-free from day one. In a dual-income household where both plans allow it, each spouse can move as much into Roth accounts in one year as a backdoor Roth IRA allows in five.


The catch: the plan has to permit after-tax (non-Roth) contributions plus an in-plan Roth conversion or in-service rollover. Many don’t. After-tax contributions are also subject to nondiscrimination testing, so highly compensated employees can have some of them refunded if the plan fails. Reading the plan document and confirming with the administrator is exactly the homework an advisor should do for you.


3. The spousal IRA


An IRA normally requires earned income. The spousal IRA is the exception: if you file jointly and have enough combined compensation, a spouse with little or no income can contribute to an IRA in their own name (IRS).


For 2026, that’s up to $7,500, or $8,600 at age 50 and older. It sounds small. It isn’t. A spouse who steps away from work for ten years to raise children or care for a parent can still contribute $75,000 over that stretch, plus growth. Many households never hear about it, and unused IRA room can’t be made up later.


If the household earns too much for a direct Roth contribution, the spousal IRA pairs with the backdoor Roth above, and the same pro-rata rules apply.


4. Withdrawal sequencing in retirement


In retirement, the question changes from “How much should I save?” to “Which account do I spend from this year?” The usual rule of thumb is taxable accounts first, then traditional IRAs, then Roth. It’s simple, and for many retirees it’s an expensive default.


Here’s why. A couple who retires at 63 and lives only on their brokerage account may report very little taxable income for years. Then required minimum distributions begin, Social Security is fully underway, and income jumps into higher brackets for the rest of their lives. That jump can also trigger Medicare IRMAA surcharges and make more of their Social Security taxable.


A better plan blends the sources. In the low-income years, take partial IRA withdrawals or Roth conversions on purpose, filling the lower brackets instead of wasting them. Later, use Roth dollars to stay under a bracket or IRMAA threshold. The right mix depends on your brackets, accounts, spending, Social Security timing and healthcare costs, but the goal is always the lowest lifetime tax bill, not the lowest bill this year. For many retirees, getting this right is worth more than any investment decision they’ll make.


5. Low-basis assets and the step-up for your children


When you die, most appreciated assets in your estate that sit outside retirement accounts receive a new cost basis equal to their value on the date of death. Decades of unrealized gains disappear for income tax purposes. There are exceptions, including retirement accounts and other income in respect of a decedent.


Take a stock bought for $50,000 that’s now worth $500,000. Sell it during your life and you owe tax on a $450,000 gain: up to about $107,000 at the top 20% capital gains rate plus the 3.8% net investment income tax. Gift it to your children and they inherit your $50,000 basis, along with the same tax bill. Leave it to them at death and their basis generally resets to $500,000. They could sell soon after and owe little or nothing.


So the planning question is simple: are you actually likely to spend this asset during your life? If not, it may belong at the bottom of your spending list and at the center of your estate plan. Spend other assets first, give appreciated shares to charity instead of cash, or borrow against the position for liquidity rather than selling it.


For married Florida residents, a Florida Community Property Trust may allow a full step-up on both halves at the first spouse’s death, instead of just one. The IRS hasn’t formally ruled on these elective trusts, and they change ownership and divorce outcomes, so this belongs in a conversation with an estate-planning attorney.


The caution: never keep a dangerously concentrated position purely to save tax. Diversification comes first.


What these strategies can add up to


Consider a hypothetical married couple, both 45, earning too much for direct Roth contributions. One spouse’s 401(k) allows after-tax contributions with in-plan Roth conversion.

Strategy

Each year

Over 20 years at a hypothetical 7%

Backdoor Roth IRA, both spouses

$15,000

about $615,000

Mega-backdoor Roth, one spouse

$37,500

about $1,537,000

Total Roth savings

$52,500

about $2,152,000

Of that roughly $2.15 million, about $1.1 million is growth that can be withdrawn tax-free under the qualified-distribution rules. Add a retirement withdrawal plan that keeps them in lower brackets, and a low-basis position that passes to their children with a step-up instead of a $107,000 tax bill, and the value of planning is measured in seven figures, not basis points.


Hypothetical illustration only. Assumes level 2026 contribution limits, end-of-year contributions, a constant 7% return and no fees. Actual results will vary.


Good advice is never one and done


None of these strategies is a box you check once. The rules move every year, and so does your life. Contribution limits and income thresholds reset annually. Employer plans add and drop features. Tax law changes, sometimes dramatically, as it did in 2025. Your income, health, family and goals shift in ways that turn last year’s right answer into this year’s mistake.


That is the real job. A good advisor should be revisiting these topics with you constantly: confirming this year’s backdoor Roth was done cleanly, checking whether a new employer’s plan allows after-tax contributions, rerunning your withdrawal plan as markets and brackets change, and updating your estate plan as your assets grow. If your advisor mostly calls when the market drops, or your reviews are mostly about performance, you are paying for the part of the job that matters least.


A simple test: did you leave your last review with a planning decision, or just a performance report?


So, are financial advisors worth the fee?


It depends entirely on what the advisor does. If the pitch is beating the market, ask for evidence and be skeptical. If the advisor finds strategies like these, implements them correctly year after year and coordinates them with your tax and estate picture, the value can far exceed the fee.


Questions to ask any advisor, including your current one:

  • What specific planning work did you complete for me this year, and what was it worth?

  • What am I paying in total, including advisory and investment expenses?

  • Have you checked whether my household qualifies for backdoor or mega-backdoor Roth contributions?

  • Do I have a written, tax-aware plan for which accounts I’ll draw from in retirement?

  • Which of my assets should I spend, and which should pass to my heirs?


Clear answers make it easy to judge whether the advice fits the fee. If you’d like a second opinion on your own situation, Atlantic Edge Private Wealth Management works with families in Ponte Vedra Beach and across Florida on exactly these decisions.


Frequently asked questions


How much does a financial advisor cost?

Most advisors charge in one of three ways: a percentage of assets they manage, a flat or retainer fee, or an hourly rate. Asset-based fees are the most common and typically decline as balances grow. Whatever the structure, ask for your total cost in dollars, including the expenses of the funds you own.


Can I do these strategies myself?

Some of them, yes. A disciplined investor can execute a backdoor Roth with care. The harder part is knowing which strategies apply to you, getting the details right every year and seeing how they interact. A Roth conversion, for example, can change your Medicare premiums and the taxation of your Social Security. That coordination is where most do-it-yourself plans break down.


What is the difference between a fee-only advisor and a commissioned one?

A fee-only advisor is paid only by clients, not by commissions on products sold. Registered investment advisers owe clients a fiduciary duty to act in their best interest. Ask any advisor how they are paid and whether they act as a fiduciary at all times.


How often should I meet with my advisor?

At least once a year for a full planning review, and whenever something significant changes: a new job, a retirement date, an inheritance, a sale of a business or a death in the family. The best advisors will reach out to you before those moments, not after.


Atlantic Edge Private Wealth Management, LLC is a registered investment adviser. This article is for educational purposes only and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Hypothetical examples are for illustration only and do not represent actual client results. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Tax rules and plan provisions vary. Consult your tax and legal advisors before acting.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page